What are the Mistakes people
are likely to commit when they apply for colleges and universities from overseas?
Number
1 in my Top 10 List of Mistakes
I have just used the phrase “top 10” to underscore the
biggest mistake people make when applying to US schools from overseas—determining
where they want to apply and then enroll based on rankings and lists. (Frankly,
all these mistakes apply to those within the US too.)
We all do it. We can’t help it. We are wired that way.* We
all too often judge things quickly and superficially. Whether it’s picking TV
shows or universities, we search for shortcuts—what is hot, cool or gucci? The shortcut that most people use when it
comes to universities is the US News rankings.
These rankings have been around for over two decades. While the US
News has the best brand there are now dozens of other rankings put out by nearly every major
media outlet. But just because The US News rankings have been around a long time and many people
judge schools based on them does not mean others should follow this common
approach to choosing schools.
There are several important reasons why rankings, whether
the US News or any others, should not
be a determinative factor in choosing schools. The first is pretty simple. They
are anything but scientific. Yes, they gather
lots of data and put all of it in a formula, but just because someone collects
numbers does not mean that the result will permit distinctions that should be valued
as the “truth” when it comes to determining which schools are best. Malcolm
Gladwell critiqued the methodology of the US
News a number of years ago and I think he was right on target:
There’s no direct way
to measure the quality of an institution—how well a college manages to inform,
inspire, and challenge its students. So the U.S. News algorithm relies instead on proxies for
quality—and the proxies for educational quality turn out to be flimsy at best.
His New Yorker piece goes on to dismantle the way US News
proxies for quality. Anyone who reads his piece will never look at rankings the
same way again. Or that is what I would hope, but I also know that I myself am
subject to the spell cast by rankings. When I see a school ranked number as one
I tend to be impressed, even if I know it isn’t based on much. If this were not
true for most of us, then clickbait would not work. But it does.
Rankings matter even if they are based on bad algorithms in
part because we have had unending advertisements and rankings flashed across
our synapses every day if not every hour that primes out mid to value them.
More importantly, reputation and spin makes something “true” even if it’s not.
(We do live, after all, in a world of "alternative facts.") In other words, we tend
to evaluate people, places, and things more on gut feelings than deep
investigative research and thought. Feelings are not facts, but they make us
act far more often than accurate stats.
If this sounds like a simple rant and against rankings, it
isn’t . I don’t think university rankings are significantly harmful to anyone as
a sizable group who work in education
seem to think, but they are not all that useful either. They are an
introductory overview of schools and so they as at least one place to
start the university search, given the
thousands of schools out there. They should not, however, be determinative,
either of the list of schools to apply to or the choice a student makes about
which school to enroll in. It is one piece that we will look at and in some
sense value, whether we want to admit it or not—neuroscience does not often
lie about the way our brains heat up and our synapses snap.
By ending here it may seem I have mislead you since have not
addressed other 9 mistakes here. Like a cliffhanger at the end of a TV Series I
hope this opening episode will keep you coming back as I work through more episodes.
* See Noble Prize winner Daniel Kahneman’s book Thinking Fast and Slow. It outlines the
way humans make decisions and it persuasively demonstrates that we are anything
but rational when choosing things and making up our minds.
I completely agree with you, these mistakes are very common now. Besides, if these students don't speak english well, they may have lots of problems with essays and etc. I can recommend this site https://findmywriters.com/best-thesis-writing-service-review/, which I often use when writing different articles and projects too.
ReplyDelete