The moment remains amazingly clear to me. I am standing in
the middle of an intersection in a small village in France. It is late
afternoon, and the light sifts through the narrow alleys that run between the
ancient, crumbling buildings. The air is still, and nothing moves. There is none
of the normal commotion. It is a perfect silence.
I am with two German and they are teaching me how to waltz. One-two-three. One -two three. I am slow and clumsy. Again: One-two-three, One-two-three.
My timing is off, and I’m misplacing the stressed downbeat. Again: One-two-three. One-two-three. My timing is off. I’m misplacing the stressed downbeat.
Again: One-two-three. One-two-three. I stumble around the
intersection, acutely aware of my lack of grace. One-two-three. One-two
three. Again, and again, and again.
One-two-three. One-two-I have it! I’m waltzing. One-two-three. One-two-three. One-two-three.
We stop, exhausted. Laughing in the middle of the quiet intersection. How
incongruous we are with the setting, yet how well matched. Suddenly, there is
clapping. Startled, we look toward the gable window from which the two wizened
Frenchmen are loudly applauding. There is, of course, only one fitting
response: I curtsy.
It does not matter what I was doing in a small French village
with two Germans. Nor is the reason I was learning to dance significant. What
is important is that at that moment, any prior boundaries I had built around my
goals were shattered. I was free!
If a girl from a small town in southwestern Virginia could
be applauded by two Frenchmen for dancing with two Germans in the middle of an
intersection in Vorges, then that same girl could at least try anything that she wished to attempt—and perhaps even succeed.
After all, hadn’t I been able to coax my unwilling feet into the complex und
unnatural pattern demanded by the waltz? One-two-three.
One-two-three. One-two-three.
‘Keep it simple’ should be the take away from this
successful college admission essay. The diction does not attempt to impress
with its sophistication. A simple word count, so to speak, demonstrates that
the words are almost all short nouns and verbs--a great many are, of course,
the numbers one two and three.
Normally repetition of this sort in a short essay would be
cause for concern. If each word is precious then why repeat the words and the
phrase so often? The writer is smart enough to know that to draw the reader in
to this magic moment, she will need to recreate the movement of the waltz.
Learning to dance, or any new skill, requires repetition and
she shows (yes, again--shows not tells) us how she did it. Nevertheless,
sometimes simplicity is much harder to accomplish than sophistication. I would
say that this essay is highly sophisticated in it structure if not in its
vocabulary.
It begins by setting a scene. For me, the word to pay
attention to for people writing college essays is “moment”. The writer recreates a moment in time. She
does this by setting the scene in time and place, adding characters and then
what is, in effect, a musical scores, the repetition of the waltz beat. As
readers, we can see the moment, hear it, and watch the movement and then
participate in the triumph of leaning the dance and the subsequent epiphany of
what this means to her.
If this were a scene
from a film or even a commercial, it would be perfectly paced. The camera
begins with a wide shot of the landscape and then pans in until we see the
people in the empty square dancing. It
would take all of a few minutes at most. And only then, after the visuals and
the soundtrack does the meaning of the event become clear. It is this moment
that has put her on a journey toward exploration and new experiences. It is
this kind of risk-taking, of a willingness to forgo convention, that schools
want to see in students. The fearlessness of attempting to learn something new
in a strange place with people not native to the region is inspiring and
indicates she will take such risks on a campus and in life past classes and a
degree.
While this student may not have had the test scores of the
writer of yesterday’s essay or attended the same famous school, her rural background
serves her well. She is not afraid to be in a new place, not afraid to try new
things, and not afraid to share her voice, simple yet oh so subtle in its
effects. She teaches each of us to waltz with her and for that any reader should be grateful.
I love this essay. I used to read it in my info sessions. And thanks for your analysis here. I'll use it, the essay and your comments, with my own students. It still works.
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for your comments Amy. I am glad this essay still resonates for you. It is deceptively simple which is a sign of high art. I hope it might inspire others too.
ReplyDelete